Report ·

Squarespace vs WordPress vs Wix vs Bernard: the small-business scorecard

A wooden mechanical scorekeeper with four rows of five round flip-discs, showing four different scores in green and cream.

Four platforms can all make a good small-business website and still leave four very different jobs for the owner.

Squarespace gives you a polished builder with the hosting taken care of. Wix gives you more freedom on the page and a growing set of business and marketing tools. Self-hosted WordPress can become almost anything, provided somebody runs it. Bernard builds or moves the site, gives you full visual and AI editing, and keeps working on it after launch.

This scorecard compares those jobs. The size and fame of the companies behind them carry no weight.

How the scoring works

The scores are for an independent business, artist, consultant, teacher or small shop in the UK. Five means the platform handles that job particularly well for that owner. One means the owner will need more tools, more technical knowledge or paid help.

They are editorial judgements. A 2/5 and every 5/5 carries a short reason in the table. The middle scores mean capable, with a qualification that is explained in the surrounding section.

There is no grand total. A photographer may care about visual editing and ignore courses. A teacher may care about private lessons and student progress more than templates. Weighting all of those equally would produce a tidy number and a poor decision.

When this article says WordPress, it means the self-hosted software from WordPress.org. WordPress.com is a managed service and belongs closer to Squarespace and Wix in a comparison like this.

Building and editing the site

CapabilityBernardSquarespaceWordPressWix
Easy to get started5/5 - built or moved for you4/52/5 - hosting and setup decisions4/5
Quality of the initial result5/5 - professionally rebuilt first4/53/53/5
Ready-made templates3/55/5 - polished template library5/5 - enormous theme selection5/5 - thousands of starting designs
Full control of the design5/5 - every page remains editable4/55/5 - virtually unlimited control5/5 - highly flexible visual canvas
Visual editing5/5 - edit directly on the page4/54/55/5 - mature on-page editor
AI-assisted editing5/5 - describe the change you want3/53/54/5
Preserve an existing design5/5 - the existing character comes across2/5 - usually rebuilt in its system3/52/5 - usually rebuilt in its system
Avoid developer costs5/5 - help is part of the product4/52/5 - specialists often become necessary4/5

Bernard combines editing freedom with managed infrastructure. In the workshop you can double-click words and type on the page, swap photographs, move and remove parts, or point at an exact spot and ask Bernard to change it. A connected ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini can work on the same draft. Nothing reaches the public site until you approve it.

Squarespace and Wix start with templates. Bernard can start from a blank brief, but its more unusual advantage is the move: an existing site becomes the starting point. That is why its template score is lower and its design-preservation score is higher. A catalogue of a thousand starting points matters less when you already have one.

WordPress remains the strongest answer when freedom means direct control of the software itself. Its official maintenance guide also makes the other side of that freedom clear: the owner is expected to update the software, check dead links, back up the site and keep it in good condition.

Speed and accessibility

CapabilityBernardSquarespaceWordPressWix
Fast without technical setup5/5 - optimised before publication4/52/5 - performance needs active tuning3/5
Cached public pages5/5 - pages are ready to serve4/53/54/5
No database needed for an ordinary page view5/5 - ordinary pages are prebuilt4/52/5 - WordPress usually builds each page4/5
Handles sudden traffic5/5 - cached pages scale naturally4/53/54/5
Image and asset optimisation5/5 - handled during publication4/53/54/5
Accessible foundations5/5 - accessibility shapes the structure4/53/54/5
Accessibility after the site changes5/5 - checks keep finding new problems3/52/5 - themes and plugins can conflict4/5

The phrase “no database” needs care. Bernard uses a database for accounts, contacts, shops, course progress and other features that hold changing information. The ordinary public pages are different: Bernard publishes them as static files and serves them through a cache. A visitor does not wait for a database to assemble the page before it appears.

That reduces the number of moving parts involved in showing a page. It helps with speed and with resistance to traffic spikes. It also removes a common public failure point. It does not make the whole service invulnerable, and the live parts still need ordinary application security.

WordPress can serve cached pages too. A good host or caching plugin can make it very quick. The score reflects the extra choice and configuration, rather than a ceiling on what WordPress can achieve.

Accessibility also needs an honest boundary. No platform can guarantee that every sentence, colour choice or uploaded image will remain accessible. Wix provides an Accessibility Wizard and Monitor, while Squarespace publishes inclusive design guidance. Both tell the owner what to check. Bernard keeps accessibility in the maintenance loop, identifies machine-detectable problems and prepares fixes on the draft. Decisions that require human knowledge, such as what a photograph shows, come back to the owner.

Security is several jobs

“Secure hosting” can hide a lot. The useful questions are who applies updates, who watches extensions, who keeps recoverable versions and what the owner has to do when something changes.

Security and recoveryBernardSquarespaceWordPressWix
Hosting security managed for you5/5 - fully managed infrastructure5/5 - Squarespace runs the infrastructure2/5 - depends on host and setup5/5 - Wix runs the infrastructure
Software updates managed for you5/5 - platform updates are automatic5/5 - platform updates are automatic2/5 - several components need attention5/5 - platform updates are automatic
Protection from unsafe extensions5/5 - integrations are checked first5/5 - no open plugin market2/5 - plugin quality and upkeep vary4/5
Secure connection and certificate5/5 - SSL is automatic5/5 - SSL is automatic3/55/5 - SSL is automatic
Automatic backups and versions5/5 - built into the service3/52/5 - another service or plugin4/5
Restore an earlier version5/5 - a year of versions is kept3/53/55/5 - site history can be restored
Security work left to the owner5/5 - Bernard looks after it5/5 - very little administration2/5 - security is continuing work5/5 - very little administration

A carefully managed WordPress site can be secure. Its score measures the responsibility left with the owner. WordPress's own security handbook says that security requires planning, monitoring and periodic maintenance, with WordPress core, plugins and themes kept current. Its backup guide explains that a complete backup needs both the database and the files.

Squarespace, Wix and Bernard take most of that job away from the owner. Squarespace issues SSL certificates automatically, though its help says the editor has no revision history. Wix provides automatic SSL and keeps a restorable site history. Bernard keeps a year of site versions, and the published site is plain files rather than a public WordPress application with a login, theme and plugin stack attached to every page request.

Shops, contacts, courses and private content

Business capabilityBernardSquarespaceWordPressWix
Predictable cost for a small shop4/53/52/5 - hosting and extensions accumulate3/5
Contacts and customer records5/5 - activity joins one contact record2/5 - limited as a working CRM3/55/5 - broad business CRM tools
Create and sell courses5/5 - courses are built in4/55/5 - powerful learning plugins4/5
Lessons and student progress5/5 - progress stays with the student3/55/5 - mature learning systems available4/5
Quizzes and certificates5/5 - marking and certificates included2/5 - limited assessment depth5/5 - specialist plugins go deep3/5
Private and members-only content5/5 - courses, memberships and invitations5/5 - member sites are built in5/5 - highly configurable access5/5 - mature member features
Paid memberships5/5 - access and payment stay connected4/55/5 - many membership systems4/5
Students connected to the CRM5/5 - every student is also a contact2/5 - limited joined-up customer view4/55/5 - students sit in the business suite

This is where a simple feature count becomes misleading. WordPress deserves its 5/5 scores because a specialist learning or membership plugin can be extremely capable. The business still has to choose the plugins, connect them and keep them compatible.

Squarespace now includes course pages, member sites and paywalled content, all described in its current capability guide. Wix also treats contacts, products, services and sales as parts of one business account.

Bernard's advantage is the join. A course student, member, buyer and mailing-list subscriber can be the same contact rather than four records living in four tools. Courses include lessons, progress, automatic quizzes and certificates. Private access can mean a paid membership, a course entitlement or a whole site opened only to invited people.

Social-media planning and publishing

Social capabilityBernardSquarespaceWordPressWix
Connect Instagram, Facebook and LinkedIn5/5 - the three networks share one calendar3/54/54/5
Plan posts in one place5/5 - site and campaigns share a plan2/5 - limited campaign planning4/55/5 - AI planner and calendar
Draft posts in the owner's voice5/5 - drafts use the business's own voice2/5 - largely left to the owner3/55/5 - brand voice guides suggestions
Adapt one idea by network5/5 - each network gets its own version2/5 - limited channel adaptation3/54/5
Preview and approve posts5/5 - nothing posts before approval2/5 - limited approval workflow3/55/5 - draft and approval workflow
Schedule and publish automatically5/5 - direct scheduled publishing2/5 - sharing rather than full management4/55/5 - built-in scheduled publishing
Explain and recover failed posts5/5 - failures have a safe next step1/5 - no recovery workflow3/54/5
Connect posts to site results5/5 - campaign links carry through2/5 - limited joined-up reporting4/54/5

Wix earns full marks here. Its social planner uses the site, goals, audience and brand voice to suggest posts, and its scheduler publishes approved work later. Wix and Bernard both do serious social-media work.

Squarespace can push newly published site content to Facebook and LinkedIn. Its own social-sharing guide describes a manual push for each item and documents limits by network. Its Unfold app creates social assets. The overall workflow is closer to sharing website content than running a joined-up calendar.

Bernard plans, drafts and publishes to Instagram, Facebook Pages and LinkedIn profiles or company Pages. The owner approves the exact words and media first. The useful difference is context: the same system knows the site pages, products, courses, contacts and wider marketing plan that the social posts are meant to support.

What happens after launch

Ongoing jobBernardSquarespaceWordPressWix
Platform upgrades applied automatically5/5 - handled by Bernard5/5 - handled by Squarespace2/5 - core, themes and plugins differ5/5 - handled by Wix
No plugin compatibility work5/5 - no customer plugin stack5/5 - no plugin stack to maintain2/5 - updates can affect each other4/5
Broken links surfaced5/5 - checked as part of upkeep3/53/53/5
Speed problems surfaced5/5 - performance stays on the work list3/53/53/5
Accessibility problems surfaced5/5 - recurring checks prepare the work3/53/55/5 - Wizard and Monitor are built in
Useful product upgrades surfaced5/5 - relevant additions are suggested3/52/5 - owner researches the options3/5
Ongoing improvement of your site5/5 - maintenance includes improvement2/5 - software upkeep is the focus2/5 - normally needs an agency2/5 - software upkeep is the focus

Squarespace and Wix maintain their platforms. Bernard also surfaces work on the customer's site. Broken links, accessibility problems, performance issues and useful new capabilities become things the owner can understand and act on. The changes still wait for approval.

This difference is easy to miss in a trial. Almost every builder feels manageable while the site is new and somebody is paying attention. The value of maintenance appears later, when a link has died, an old page is misleading people or a feature has arrived that would replace another subscription.

Features you may never need

Bernard has a smaller template catalogue and no open market containing tens of thousands of plugins. It is not designed as a server-control panel, a multi-warehouse retail system or a home for every experimental WordPress extension.

Those are real limitations. They matter to a business that needs them. Many independents never will.

Features worth treating as optional rather than automatically valuable include:

  • thousands of templates after the business already has a recognisable design;
  • direct access to PHP, databases and server configuration;
  • an open plugin market that also creates an update and compatibility job;
  • multi-location warehouse and stock-management machinery;
  • native point-of-sale hardware for several physical shops;
  • hotel, restaurant or enterprise approval systems built into the website platform;
  • controls for maintaining themes, caches and plugins that would not otherwise exist.

Ask whether a missing item would change the day-to-day running of your business. The longest feature list rarely answers that.

If you need unusual server software, a vast plugin choice or complex international retail, WordPress or a specialist commerce platform will probably suit you better. If you want the site, contacts, social posts, shop, courses and private content to be one maintained system, Bernard is built around that shape of business.

Who should choose each one

Choose Squarespace when you want a polished template, straightforward editing and little technical maintenance. It suits a conventional site or small shop whose owner is happy to manage the content and marketing work.

Choose WordPress when the site needs an unusual feature, direct developer control or a specialist plugin, and somebody has accepted responsibility for keeping the system healthy.

Choose Wix when visual freedom and a broad business suite matter. Its CRM, accessibility tools and social planner are stronger than the old description of Wix as a simple drag-and-drop builder suggests.

Choose Bernard when you want full visual and AI editing without taking on the hosting, security and maintenance job. It suits a business that wants the website connected to contacts, selling, teaching, private content and social publishing, with improvements continuing after launch.

For current prices and worked two-year examples, see the best website builder for a small business. For the choices in pairs, see Squarespace vs WordPress, Squarespace vs Wix and Wix vs WordPress.


See what Bernard would do with your business. Paste your current address and he will measure it up, free, and show you the new place before you decide anything. Starting from nothing? Tell him what you are building.

Questions people ask

Which website platform is easiest for a small business?
Wix and Squarespace are easy places to build a site yourself. Bernard goes further by building or moving the site, then helping with the work after launch. Self-hosted WordPress asks the most of its owner because hosting, updates, plugins, security and backups all need decisions.
Is WordPress better than Squarespace or Wix?
WordPress is better when you need an unusual feature, an open plugin market or control of the server and files. Squarespace and Wix are easier when nobody wants to maintain the software. The right answer depends on whether flexibility or reduced upkeep matters more to your business.
Can Bernard be edited like Wix or Squarespace?
Yes. You can edit words and images directly on the page, use the visual editor, or describe a change to Bernard or a connected AI. Every change waits on a draft until you approve it. Bernard combines editing control with managed hosting.

You might also want to read

Built with BernardCookie settings